Polyamory : A wise choice or just plain greedy?

Polyamory is a term that was new to me until a few weeks ago and might indeed be one new to you today but it addresses a big problem of trust and fidelity – something important to us all whatever the relationship.

Poly (many) amory (loves) shouldn’t be confused with swinging or an open relationship or just plain old fashioned cheating.  To be poly amorous means to have/pursue a loving romantic relationship with more than one person without judgement. www.polyamory.org.uk

The main components that can damage a relationship can be mistrust, infidelity and the inability to commit.  This alternative seems to help with the massive life choice of choosing one person forever and worrying as to whether that choice is the right one.  For me, I never trusted myself enough to commit, making any partner of mine feel vulnerable and dissatisfied and often causing infidelity.  What if upfront I’d have said ‘what about we say that from the start we both have alternatives – we love each other but know that if we feel the need to date other people then we can’.  Personally I love dates, finding out about people, the first time sex and the connection that develops – it’s exciting and fulfilling.

polyamory three way infidelity

3 way 4 way and more ways

Scepticism surrounds this whole way of life but talking to Lori and Amanda who find themselves in this situation made things seem so much clearer.  Lori had been in a relationship with John for 13 years.  He introduced her to the idea of other partners early on.  Lori had always had an issue with being faithful to one person so to be able to experiment seemed ideal.  For Lori and John swinging became dull and like with most sex dates they can be awkward and shallow.

John met Amanda through OK Cupid – a site designed for people in relationships looking to experiment.  Amanda wanted a bit of fun but suddenly found she had fallen in love with John and him with her, which meant Amanda, who to this point had only been monogamous, was introduced to the idea of polyamory.  Many couples choose to never meet their partners partners but Lori and Amanda did and they like each other – they share time and the fact everything is so honest means there is little jealousy or tension.

It is purely society that tells us that we need to choose one person.  In Western civilisation we are in fact the oddity as most cultures embrace the idea of more than one partner.  So many films/books dictate that we must choose – look at Bella in Twilight, Catherine in Wuthering Heights and The Hunger Games.  Even dating shows like Take Me Out involve picking one of 20 girls – why not date five of them?  With choosing there is rarely a good feeling during the process.  The chooser feels guilt and loss and the one not chosen feels unjust rejection.

It is rare that one person can offer us everything we need – in other areas of our life we don’t have to choose so why not in relationships.  I have many friends – some I love for their humour, their knowledge, their love of music; others for their willingness to travel, love of sport and dancing.  It doesn’t mean I love one more than the other – just combined they leave me fulfilled.

Lori told me that when people cannot get to grips with polyamory she describes it as like having a second child.  As parents, when you have one child you feel you could never love another child as much as the first – that would be impossible, but then you have a second child.  That second child might be different to the first, but you love it just the same.  In fact seeing both children interact makes you love them both more and your family feels even more complete.

polyamory infidelity love triangle

Polyamory family life

This idea isn’t for everyone.  Often open relationships will turn sour if rules are broken just like monogamous ones and often it’s easier to deal with a partner having base line sex with someone rather than romance.  Much like it can be human nature to want display lust, the other six deadly sins are never far behind.  We go through lives avoiding loss – polyamorous couples feel that if someone wants to leave it is inevitable – monogamous or otherwise though I can’t help feeling waving temptation under someone’s nose – giving them a bite of the apple might make someone consider something they had previously never thought an option.

I admire those who can be polyamorous as trust is so hard and to split that three ways is even harder.  For those of us that feel like a constant failure in a monogamous relationship then it gives hope that, just like being straight or gay, being with one person isn’t  always natural so don’t fight it as other people aren’t, in fact they’re embracing it and are bloody happy.


A thirty something, fifties inspired traveller with a love of home comforts and pretty things. Lives in Norwich, plays in London.

'Polyamory : A wise choice or just plain greedy?' have 7 comments

  1. May 29, 2013 @ 10:04 pm ?

    Did amanda ever forgive Jon?


  2. June 1, 2013 @ 11:24 am Mando

    In my post Amanda, Jon and Lori were in a consensual three way relationship. The only way any relationship survives is with trust and truth. That’s how these three make it work. If one of you in the relationship is a pathological liar out for his own gain then it will never work,


  3. June 1, 2013 @ 7:13 pm ?

    Totally agree! ! And only terrible things come from lies and decipt!. Should a relationship have to survive? Surely it should be easier then that!?


  4. June 2, 2013 @ 8:06 am Mando

    No a relationship shouldn’t have to survive. It’s tragic when a relationship ends but more tragic to keep one going if its not working. Most people aren’t brave enough to break a routine or a heart though and will keep slogging away. I was with someone for a while when I wasn’t in love with them and when it finally ended he said I’d done the worse thing of all as I’d stolen time, something you can’t get back or buy more of. I’ll only be with the right person from now on – someone I would rather cut my arm off rather than lie to and deceive. Someone that makes me want to be a better person so they love me.


  5. June 2, 2013 @ 9:13 pm ?

    Time is wasted daily…watching tv, playing games and yes shitty relationships! I feel that the majority of my life I am happy and content but in reality not knowing what would truly make me smile! As for your arm, don’t cut it off as nobody is worth being disabled for! tin openers are a bugger with only one hand! But yes liars and cheats really are not worth the trouble.


  6. June 3, 2013 @ 7:12 am Mando

    Well maybe polyamory is for you. You just have to convince the missis. You seem talented at convincing her over most things so I’m sure it won’t be a problem.


  7. June 3, 2013 @ 7:35 am ?

    Hahaha yes the thought is nice but in reality…. 2 women to keep happy constantly, 2 lots of pmt and 2 lists of jobs to do every weekend! Think I will sit that one out! 🙂


Would you like to share your thoughts?

Your email address will not be published.

Copyright Spicenotsugar.co.uk 2014